Presiding over an increasingly contentious
trial, Judge Stern wearily watches an attorney cross-examine
an obviously hostile witness. As the witness, an African-American
woman, complains for the fifth time that a question
is unclear, the exasperated counsel shoots back at her: "Come on, honey, you didnt just step out
of a cotton patch. You know exactly what Im asking
you." Opposing counsel does not object.
Should
Judge Stern take any action?
1. Yes, Judge Stern
should admonish the attorney to avoid any racially
discriminatory remarks in court and to apologize to
the witness.
2. Yes, Judge Stern
should hold counsel in contempt.
3. No, Judge Stern
can do nothing because opposing counsel did not object.
4. No, because counsels
conduct is a legitimate, if indelicate, attempt to
get an evasive witness to testify.
|